The Other Son

This is the d’var Torah I delivered at Congregation Neveh Shalom on Friday, November 13, 2026.


There’s a beautiful and poignant song by Maddie Zahm that I highly recommend you search for after Shabbat. It’s called “Mothers and Daughters,” and she sings it from the perspective of a daughter, realizing she’s becoming her mother.

Sometimes I hear myself say something to my children and realize halfway through the sentence that I sound exactly like Cindy Posen. Sometimes I’m grateful. And sometimes I understand, with remarkable clarity, why my children are rolling their eyes. And sometimes I wonder what else I’ve learned from the adults who raised me that I only notice when I hear it coming out of my own mouth.

In Parshat Toldot, Isaac and Rebecca raise two sons. The Torah tells us plainly that Isaac loves Esau and Rebecca loves Jacob. When Isaac grows old, Rebecca helps Jacob disguise himself as his brother and receive the blessing Isaac intended for Esau. When Esau discovers what has happened, he cries out, “Have you only one blessing, Father?” (Genesis 27:38)

I wonder what Isaac hears in that cry. Years earlier, his own father faced a demand to choose between his sons. Sarah insists that Abraham send Hagar and Ishmael away so that Ishmael will have no share in Isaac’s inheritance. The Torah tells us this grieves Abraham because Ishmael is his son. God promises that Ishmael, too, will become a nation. And still, in the morning, Abraham sends him away. Isaac grows up as the son who stays. Now he hears what it sounds like to be the other son.

There’s another story about Isaac in this parshah. He digs out Abraham’s wells and calls them by the names his father gave them. Isaac knows exactly what he’s preserving when he restores those wells. I wonder how much harder it is to recognize what we’re carrying forward when it’s a way of loving our children. What did Isaac learn about what a father owes each of his sons? Did he ever have a chance to ask?

Esau’s question, “Have you only one blessing, Father?” stays with me because children are so often the first to say aloud what the adults in a family have learned to live with. They notice who gets forgiven, who is expected to be the easy one, and whose hurt everyone has learned to explain away. Sometimes they ask us about it at the very moment we’re sure we’ve been fair.

This Shabbat, think of a story your family tells about the way things have always been. Ask someone from another generation how they remember it. Listen especially for the person whose version you rarely hear. There may be a blessing you’ve been waiting for from the generation before you. There may also be one that someone is still waiting to hear from you.

Leave a Reply